Book challenge: Book over 700 pages
This book (and its subsequent two books because it’s a trilogy) have been all over the book boards. Everyone LOVES The Bronze Horseman so I decided to buy it.
I have a lot to say so, while I will try to
make my review shorter than its 800 pages, I will break this review into two
parts: The non-spoiler and spoiler
reviews.
Summary
Summary
The Bronze Horseman starts with the entrance of the USSR
into World War II in June 1941.
Tatiana lives in Leningrad with her family and meets Alexander, an officer in the Red Army. The two soon fall in love. But, with Germany’s siege of Leningrad and no supplies able to get in, Tatiana, Alexander, and all of Leningrad must struggle through the long winter dealing with constant bombings and almost no food. In the midst of their fight for survival, Tatiana must deal with her feelings for Alexander and her desire not to betray her beloved sister.
Tatiana lives in Leningrad with her family and meets Alexander, an officer in the Red Army. The two soon fall in love. But, with Germany’s siege of Leningrad and no supplies able to get in, Tatiana, Alexander, and all of Leningrad must struggle through the long winter dealing with constant bombings and almost no food. In the midst of their fight for survival, Tatiana must deal with her feelings for Alexander and her desire not to betray her beloved sister.
Non-Spoiler
I had some major eye-roll and side-eye moments as I read
this (see the spoiler review) but all in all, it wasn’t terrible. In fact, I actually got pretty in to this book and had a hard time putting it down because it very easy to read and I wanted to know what was going to happen. But, I will say that I expected more considering all the acclaim.
Spoiler (or “Things
that really annoyed me about this book”)
I am going to break this down by specific topics
The Metric System
From page 342:
Alexander's rations helped them stretch their food supplies a little longer. He got a king's ration - 800 grams of bread per day!- more than half of what they were getting for the five of them. He also received 150 grams of meat and 140 of cereals and a half a kilo of vegetables.
Throughout the whole long winter, everything is measured in
grams.
I am not a scientist.
I am an American.
I don’t use the metric system so I have no idea what this means. I know a kilogram would be like a pound give or take but after that, 125 grams of bread? What does that mean? They could have at least displayed a table to convert or did a footnote that said X number of grams equals 1 slice of bread. Either way, I got that it wasn’t a lot but still... And yes I realize that it was more true to the situation to write in the metric system. But still...
I am not a scientist.
I am an American.
I don’t use the metric system so I have no idea what this means. I know a kilogram would be like a pound give or take but after that, 125 grams of bread? What does that mean? They could have at least displayed a table to convert or did a footnote that said X number of grams equals 1 slice of bread. Either way, I got that it wasn’t a lot but still... And yes I realize that it was more true to the situation to write in the metric system. But still...
The Soviet Union
After reading this book, I am extremely happy to have been
born in capitalistic America and not the USSR.
Yikes! That is all I can say.
Tatiana’s Learns English
Tatiana’s Learns English
Tatiana never spoke English but yet one phrase book and a couple of conversations later, she is a pro. Eye roll and side-eye combo. Of course since Russian and English are so close, I can see how she was able to do it.
The Dasha Question
One of the most annoying things to me about this book was
Tatiana meets Alexander.
Tatiana finds out that Alexander went on a date or whatever with her sister.
Tatiana knows Dasha likes him.
Tatiana tells Alexander she can’t continue with him because of her sister.
Alexander decides he can’t be without Tatiana so he decides to continue dating Dasha to the point where they become engaged. His justification: “I need to be near you”. Uh ok. I would have a major problem if Mr. one day said, “Hey I am with you so I can be near your sister.” Um yeah. This is a good idea how? This just seemed so dumb to me, I don’t even have words. It’s fortunate the war came and everyone got killed off I guess or how was this supposed to resolve itself otherwise?
Alexander is a selfish,
douche.
That is all.
Alexander is always
able to get away from the front to attend to Tatiana.
I am positive this is how it would happen in real life
Soviet Russia. Please.
The Honeymoon
I am going to cover a few things here.
1. Simons constantly refers to the fact that Tatiana is "so small" and Alexander is "so big". Please. Cliche train!
2. Alexander is whoring around town using Tatiana's sister but expects her (Tatiana) to "save herself" for him and gets mad at the idea of her even hanging out with other men. Uh ok.
3. So we've established that Tatiana is this meek, little woman and Alexander this experienced, big man whore. Let's go to their honeymoon.
From about 520 to 630, the story became a torrid romance novel.
Every three second, these two were at it like rabbits.
For example:
"Tatiana those are some nice pancakes you are making..."
Sex scene
Five minutes later in the story, "Oh Alexander, that is a big fish you caught..."
Sex scene
"What time is it..."
Sex scene
You get the idea.
It got old pretty fast. I stuck through the 100 pages of this but it could have really been edited down. Frankly, I thought the whole thing was unrealistic and absurd.
I read Mr. some of these scenes because they were so ridiculous and he said "It sounds like a desperate housewife wrote that as some kind of fantasy".
The Honeymoon
I am going to cover a few things here.
1. Simons constantly refers to the fact that Tatiana is "so small" and Alexander is "so big". Please. Cliche train!
2. Alexander is whoring around town using Tatiana's sister but expects her (Tatiana) to "save herself" for him and gets mad at the idea of her even hanging out with other men. Uh ok.
3. So we've established that Tatiana is this meek, little woman and Alexander this experienced, big man whore. Let's go to their honeymoon.
From about 520 to 630, the story became a torrid romance novel.
Every three second, these two were at it like rabbits.
For example:
"Tatiana those are some nice pancakes you are making..."
Sex scene
Five minutes later in the story, "Oh Alexander, that is a big fish you caught..."
Sex scene
"What time is it..."
Sex scene
You get the idea.
It got old pretty fast. I stuck through the 100 pages of this but it could have really been edited down. Frankly, I thought the whole thing was unrealistic and absurd.
I read Mr. some of these scenes because they were so ridiculous and he said "It sounds like a desperate housewife wrote that as some kind of fantasy".




